Bilingual Disparities Review Meeting Notes

06 Sep 2024

Stephanie Grasso Maria Quinones Vieta Rylee Manning

Manuscript:
Methods Section

• Target journal: AJSLP

  • AJSLP journal guidelines are in Box folder

• Organize the Methods section similar to the Scoping review and the ANCDS review

Criteria Section

• Create a table with search terms (similar to the one in Scoping Review)

  • Use Excel to create the tables; use different tabs in the spreadsheet for each table

Data Items Section

• Reference the ANCDS review and only briefly summarize the main items that were rated. Mention that it is already published and open access. Then, include describe the items that were rated for our review in more detail.

Results Section

• Report general features of the studies and our newly extracted info

Tasks

• Rylee Manning will finish double-checking her ratings for papers 146-149.
• Once all data for the ratings are included in the spreadsheet, Maria Quinones Vieta and Rylee Manning can check final reliability scores for all reviewers
• Rylee Manning and Maria Quinones Vietawill establish mutual consensus for papers where reviewers showed discrepancy for Explicit vs. Implied Criteria 
• Next week, Stephanie Grasso Maria Quinones Vieta Rylee Manning will look at examples of papers with ambiguity regarding eligibility criteria (i.e. whether it was implied or explicit) and decide on tie-breakers for these instances